• Our Services
  • Our Method
  • Team
  • Sales
  • Rentals
  • Furnished
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
  1. Home
  2. 444 East 57th Street, 5C
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
  • View All Photos
  • View Floor Plans
  • Request an Appointment

444 East 57th Street, 5C

Sutton Place | NY
First Avenue & Sutton Place

Schedule a Viewing
New This Week
$ 1,399,000
Active
Status
5
Rooms
2
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,240/115
ASF/ASM
$ 1,535
Real Estate Taxes [Monthly]
$ 2,383
Common Charges [Monthly]
90%
Financing Allowed
  • 444 East 57th Street, 5C
  • 5 Rooms
  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • $ 1,399,000

Photos

444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Floor Plan

444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Description

Step into 444 East 57th Street, Residence 5C — a rare opportunity to own a piece of Manhattan’s golden age. This 1929 pre-war condominium, located on one of Sutton Place’s most serene and elegant blocks, once welcomed the likes of Marilyn Monroe and Arthur Miller, letting residents stroll the same halls as Hollywood’s most iconic stars. Boasting approximately 1,240 square feet, this home exudes the warmth, charm, and architectural character that make classic pre-war residences so coveted. The living room is generously sized and features a wood-burning fireplace complete with an ornate mantle, creating a sophisticated yet inviting setting. The south and west exposures, ensures that the space receives a warm, gentle glow throughout the day. The layout includes two well-proportioned bedrooms, two polished marble bathrooms, and a windowed kitchen equipped with a vented washer/dryer. Ideal for entertaining, a separate formal dining room provides the perfecct space for hosting dinners and gatherings. Features in this home include high ceilings with beams, beautiful trim work, hardwood flooring, and breathtaking arched doorways. Generous closets - some cedar lined, enhance the home's appeal and practicality. This intimate condominium offers the convenience of a full-service staff, including a 24-hour doorman, concierge, and a full-time elevator attendant — an amenity so rare in today’s New York City that only a small handful of buildings still offer it. This classic service not only adds a layer of ease and security but also reflects the timeless elegance that defines 444 East 57th Street. Flexible ownership options are permitted, including pied-à-terres, subletting, LLC and trust ownership. A standout location: Sutton Place is one of Manhattan’s most peaceful and established neighborhoods, known for its leafy streets, classic architecture, and understated luxury. Residents enjoy close proximity to top dining and shopping, Whole Foods, and charming local markets. The East River Promenade is just moments away for morning runs or sunset walks. Despite the tranquility, transportation options are abundant, offering quick access to Midtown, the Upper East Side, and beyond. It’s a rare pocket of calm in the heart of the city — the perfect blend of neighborhood charm and urban convenience. The sale includes a private storage area, and the building permits pets. Contact us for a private showing.
Step into 444 East 57th Street, Residence 5C — a rare opportunity to own a piece of Manhattan’s golden age. This 1929 pre-war condominium, located on one of Sutton Place’s most serene and elegant blocks, once welcomed the likes of Marilyn Monroe and Arthur Miller, letting residents stroll the same halls as Hollywood’s most iconic stars. Boasting approximately 1,240 square feet, this home exudes the warmth, charm, and architectural character that make classic pre-war residences so coveted. The living room is generously sized and features a wood-burning fireplace complete with an ornate mantle, creating a sophisticated yet inviting setting. The south and west exposures, ensures that the space receives a warm, gentle glow throughout the day. The layout includes two well-proportioned bedrooms, two polished marble bathrooms, and a windowed kitchen equipped with a vented washer/dryer. Ideal for entertaining, a separate formal dining room provides the perfecct space for hosting dinners and gatherings. Features in this home include high ceilings with beams, beautiful trim work, hardwood flooring, and breathtaking arched doorways. Generous closets - some cedar lined, enhance the home's appeal and practicality. This intimate condominium offers the convenience of a full-service staff, including a 24-hour doorman, concierge, and a full-time elevator attendant — an amenity so rare in today’s New York City that only a small handful of buildings still offer it. This classic service not only adds a layer of ease and security but also reflects the timeless elegance that defines 444 East 57th Street. Flexible ownership options are permitted, including pied-à-terres, subletting, LLC and trust ownership. A standout location: Sutton Place is one of Manhattan’s most peaceful and established neighborhoods, known for its leafy streets, classic architecture, and understated luxury. Residents enjoy close proximity to top dining and shopping, Whole Foods, and charming local markets. The East River Promenade is just moments away for morning runs or sunset walks. Despite the tranquility, transportation options are abundant, offering quick access to Midtown, the Upper East Side, and beyond. It’s a rare pocket of calm in the heart of the city — the perfect blend of neighborhood charm and urban convenience. The sale includes a private storage area, and the building permits pets. Contact us for a private showing.

Listing Courtesy of Compass

Features

A/C
Washer / Dryer

View / Exposure

North, East, South, West Exposures
444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Building Details

444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022
Condo
Ownership
Mid-Rise
Building Type
Full Service
Service Level
Attended Elevator
Access
Pets Allowed
Pet Policy
1368/7501
Block/Lot
Pre-War
Age
1929
Year Built
14/45
Floors/Apts

Building Amenities

Bike Room
Common Storage
Garden
Laundry Room
Private Storage

Building Statistics

$ 1,121 APPSF

Closed Sales Data [Last 12 Months]

444 East 57th Street 5C Sutton Place New York NY 10022

Contact

License Licensed As: Jay M. Heydt
Jay Heydt

Jay Heydt

License Licensed As: Jay M. Heydt

Principal Broker

W: 646-234-5815
M: 646-234-5815
Contact Agent Download VCard

Mortgage Calculator

$
%
$
%

Loan Amount

This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2025 REBNY Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. All information is intended only for the Registrant’s personal, non-commercial use. RLS Data display by Vertical Real Estate. Additional building data provided by On-Line Residential [OLR].
All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
Listing ID: 2122344